Visual Acuity, Contrast Sensitivity and Color Vision Three Years After Iodine-125 Brachytherapy for Choroidal and Ciliary Body Melanoma
Irena Tsui 1, Robert M Beardsley 1, Tara A McCannel 1, Scott C Oliver 2, Melissa W Chun 1, Steve P Lee 3, Phillip E Chow 3, Nzhde Agazaryan 3, Fei Yu 1, Bradley R Straatsma*, 1
Identifiers and Pagination:Year: 2015
First Page: 131
Last Page: 135
Publisher ID: TOOPHTJ-9-131
Article History:Received Date: 13/2/2015
Revision Received Date: 29/4/2015
Acceptance Date: 11/5/2015
Electronic publication date: 26/6/2015
Collection year: 2015
open-access license: This is an open access article licensed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/) which permits unrestricted, non-commercial use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the work is properly cited.
To report visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after and 3 years after iodine-125 brachytherapy for choroidal and ciliary body melanoma (CCM).
Prospective interventional case series.
Thirty-seven patients (37 eyes) with CCM.
Patients had best-corrected Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) visual acuity, Pelli-Robson contrast sensitivity and Hardy-Rand-Rittler color vision measurement; comprehensive ophthalmology examination; optical coherence tomography; and ultrasonography at baseline prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after and 3 years after I-125 brachytherapy.
Main Outcome Measures :
Visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after and 3 years after brachytherapy.
Nineteen (19) men and 18 women with mean age of 58 years (SD 13, range 30-78) prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after and 3 years after brachytherapy had mean best-corrected visual acuity of 77 letters (20/32), 65 letters (20/50), 56 letters (20/80) and 47 letters (20/125); contrast sensitivity of 30, 26, 22 and 19 letters; color vision of 26, 20, 17 and 14 test figures, respectively. Decrease in visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision was statistically significant from baseline at 1 year, 2 years, and 3 years after brachytherapy. Decreased acuity at 3 years was associated with mid-choroid and macula melanoma location, ≥ 4.1 mm melanoma height, radiation maculopathy and radiation optic neuropathy.
1, 2 and 3 years after brachytherapy, eyes with CCM had significantly decreased visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision.
Choroidal and ciliary body melanoma (CCM) is the most common primary intraocular malignancy in adults. Overall incidence of uveal melanoma is reported as approximately 5.1 per million per year in the United States .
The Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) randomized clinical trial of iodine-125 (I-125) brachytherapy versus enucleation for medium-sized choroidal melanoma (2.5 – 10.0 mm in thickness and ≤ 16.0 mm in diameter) showed that, for patients who met the eligibility criteria, there was no statistically significant difference in all-cause mortality between I-125 brachytherapy and enucleation 5, 10 and 12 years following treatment [2-4].
The COMS trial supported the use of globe-conserving I-125 brachytherapy. However, adverse effects of I-125 brachytherapy included dry eye and keratopathy, iris neovascularization and glaucoma, radiation cataract, radiation maculopathy and radiation optic neuropathy [5-11]. Reflecting these adverse effects, the COMS reported median visual acuity following I-125 brachytherapy for medium-sized choroidal melanoma in 623 patients (623 eyes) as 20/32 at baseline prior to brachytherapy and 20/125 3 years after brachytherapy .
This current study was carried out, in accordance with a previously reported protocol , to further evaluate the effect of I-125 brachytherapy for CCM on central visual function by measurement of best-corrected visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after, and 3 years after brachytherapy.
MATERIALS AND METHODOLOGY
This prospective interventional case study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and approved by the Institutional Review Board of the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA). Informed consent was obtained from all patients and the study adhered to provisions of the United States Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996.
Adult patients with CCM undergoing I-125 brachytherapy were eligible to enroll unless there was ocular disease unrelated to melanoma affecting central visual function of either eye, prior radiation therapy to the head or medical condition likely to interfere with 3 year follow-up. Baseline evaluation was performed ≤ 30 days prior to brachytherapy and post-treatment evaluation was carried out 1 year, 2 years and 3 years after brachytherapy. Pretreatment and post-treatment evaluation included protocol refraction immediately prior to each visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision measurement; comprehensive ophthalmic examination; fundus photography; optical coherence tomography; and ultrasonography. Fluorescein angiography was performed at baseline and as clinically indicated thereafter.
Visual Acuity. After refraction performed in accordance with the COMS Protocol , best-corrected visual acuity was measured as the number of letters read with each eye at 3.2 m (or at 1.6 m or 0.8 m if necessary) using the Ferris-Bailey Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) visual acuity chart (The Lighthouse, Inc., Long Island City, NY) with standardized lighting. Snellen equivalent acuities of the ETDRS score were calculated from COMS Chart 02 .
Contrast Sensitivity. Contrast sensitivity was measured as the number of letters with decreasing contrast recognized with each eye on a standard luminance background [12, 13]. Contrast threshold was assessed at one meter with the Pelli-Robson Contrast Sensitivity Chart (Clement Clark, Dayton, OH), using standardized lighting and +0.75 D add over the distance refraction. For acuities below 20/320, the chart distance was shortened so that the letters appeared at twice the acuity threshold.
Color Vision. Hardy-Rand-Rittler Pseudoisochromatic Color Test Plates, 4th Edition (Richmond Products, Inc., Albuquerque, NM), were used to assess color vision in each eye with standardized illumination at 0.75 m. and +1.25 D add over the distance vision. Correct responses to 28 diagnostic figures were scored.
Iodine-125 Brachytherapy. I-125 brachytherapy for CCM has been described elsewhere [14, 15]. Briefly, melanomas were treated to a target dose of 85 Gy at the tumor apex. Gold plaques consistent with COMS standards covered the tumor base and a surrounding margin of 3 mm. Under monitored local anesthesia and akinesia achieved with retrobulbar block, partial or 360-degree conjunctival peritomy was performed, rectus muscles were isolated and detached with a hang-back suture when required for plaque placement. Tumor borders were localized with transillumination and confirmed with indirect ophthalmoscopy. Transscleral fine needle aspiration biopsy was performed for cytopathology and cytogenetic study. The plaque was secured in position with 5-0 Mersilene sutures and placement was confirmed with intraoperative B-scan ultrasonography. The plaque remained in place for the duration determined by radiation dosimetry calculations and was removed under monitored local anesthesia.
Statistical Analysis. Statistical analysis used SAS version 9.1 (Cary, NC). Difference in visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision from baseline to 1 year, 2 years, and 3 years after brachytherapy, and difference in visual acuity from baseline to three years for melanoma location, melanoma thickness, cataract, maculopathy and optic neuropathy were assessed with the Wilcoxon signed rank test. Association of maculopathy and optic neuropathy with radiation dose was evaluated with the Fisher exact test and the Kruskal-Wallis test. P-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Thirty-seven patients (37 eyes) with CCM (TNIM Classification T2a and T2b)  consisted of 19 (52%) men and 18 (48%) women with mean age at brachytherapy of 58 years (SD 13 years, range 30-78 years). Ethnicity was White 33 (90%), Hispanic 2 (5%), and Asian 2 (5%). There were 19 left eyes and 18 right eyes.
For all CCM eyes at baseline prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after, and 3 years after brachytherapy, mean visual acuity was 77 letters (20/32), 65 letters (20/50), 56 letters (20/80) and 47 letters (20/125); contrast sensitivity was 30 letters, 26 letters, 22 letters and 19 letters; color vision was 26 figures, 20 figures, 17 figures and 14 figures, respectively (Table 1). Decrease in visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision from baseline at 1 year, 2 years and 3 years was statistically significant (Table 1).
Visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision three years after iodine-125 brachytherapy.
|Central Vision||Baseline||1 Year||2 Years||3 Years|
|Mean+/-SD letters||76.7+/-20.2 (20/32)||65.3+/-28.0 (20/50)||55.6+/-34.6 (20/80)||46.6+/-37.2 (20/125)|
|Contrast Sensitivity Letters|
Melanoma location, melanoma apical height and visual acuity outcome.
|Visual Acuity: Mean+/SD (Letters)||P-Value*|
|Baseline||1 Year||2 Years||3 Years|
|Mid choroid, n=16||85.5+/-15.7||72.5+/-21.0||61.1+/-34.8||43.6+/-41.1||0.002|
|Melanoma Apical Height|
|≤4.0 mm, n=21||78.8+/-16.5||72.9+/-22.9||64.4+/-33.0||58.2+/-37.4||0.051|
|≥4.1 mm, n=16||74.0+/-24.5||55.4+/-31.6||44.1+/-34.2||34.9+/-34.3||<0.0001|
* CB/Anterior = ciliary body (3) and anterior (pre-equatorial) choroid (5).
Furthermore, 1 year after, 2 years after and 3 years after brachytherapy, change in visual acuity was statistically significantly correlated with change in contrast sensitivity (Spearman correlation coefficient=0.87 (p<0.0001), 0.91 (p<0.0001) and 0.90 (p<0.0001) respectively) and change in color vision (Spearman correlation coefficient=0.50 (p=0.005), 0.79 (p=<0.0001) and 0.78 (p<0.0001) respectively). Therefore, decrease in visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision were significantly correlated and generally declined simultaneously after brachytherapy.
At baseline, visual acuity was ≥ 20/20 in 15 (41%) eyes and ≤ 20/200 in 2 (5%) eyes. Three years after brachytherapy, visual acuity was ≥ 20/20 in 4 (11%) eyes and ≤ 20/200 in 15 (41%) eyes (Table 1).
Analysis of CCM location and visual acuity showed location-dependent vision loss. At baseline and 3 years after brachytherapy, ciliary body/anterior (pre-equatorial) choroid tumors (n = 8) had a mean visual acuity of 76 letters and 77 letters respectively, mid-choroid tumors (n = 16) 85 letters and 44 letters, and macula tumors (n = 13) 66 letters and 32 letters (Table 2). The decrease in visual acuity for ciliary body/anterior choroid tumors was not significant (p=0.41), whereas mid-choroid and macula tumors had statistically significant change in visual acuity (p=0.002 and 0.006 respectively).
Melanoma apical height and visual acuity loss showed a significant correlation for thicker tumors. Melanomas with apical height of ≤ 4.0 mm (n = 21) had a mean visual acuity decrease from 79 letters to 58 letters, a decrease of borderline statistical significance (p=0.051), whereas melanomas ≥ 4.1 mm in apical height (n = 16) had a mean decrease from 74 letters to 35 letters, a decrease that was statistically significant (p<0.0001, Table 2).
Radiation Cataract, Maculopathy and Optic Neuropathy. Radiation cataract, defined as visually significant progression of 2+ or greater lens opacity compared to the fellow eye, developed in 13 (41%) of 32 eyes phakic at time of brachytherapy and was associated with significant decrease in mean visual acuity from 72 letters at baseline to 31 letters 3 years after brachytherapy (p=0.008). This decrease in visual acuity in eyes with cataract was somewhat greater than the decrease in eyes aphakic at baseline or without cataract 3 years after brachytherapy, but the difference was not statistically significant (p=0.36). This is consistent with the practice of cataract surgery when clinically indicated.
Radiation maculopathy was identified by clinical abnormalities and, when indicated, by fluorescein angiography in 21 (57%) of 37 eyes and associated with a significant decrease in mean visual acuity from 72 letters at baseline to 27 letters 3 years after brachytherapy (p<0.0001).
Radiation optic neuropathy was diagnosed on the basis of optic disc pallor in 4 (11%) of 37 eyes and associated with severe decrease in vision from 45 letters at baseline to <1 letter 3 years after brachytherapy, a decrease that was clinically but not statistically significant in this limited sample (p=0.13).
Fellow Eye Visual Function. The 37 unaffected fellow eyes had a baseline mean best-corrected visual acuity of 90 letters (20/16), contrast sensitivity of 35 letters, and color vision of 28 figures, measurements that were significantly better than the corresponding baseline measurements in CCM eyes (p<0.0001, 0.0001 and 0.005 respectively). Three years after brachytherapy, mean best-corrected visual acuity in fellow eyes remained at 90 letters (20/16).
This study of best-corrected visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after, and 3 years after globe-conserving I-125 brachytherapy for CCM provided new information regarding important parameters of brachytherapy-related vision impairment, confirmed major risk factors for brachytherapy-related vision loss and compared vision parameters in CCM eyes with corresponding measurements in unaffected fellow eyes.
For the first time, to our knowledge, contrast sensitivity and color vision measurement were systematically combined with assessment of best-corrected visual acuity to demonstrate the extent of central vision impairment following brachytherapy for uveal melanoma. Snellen visual acuity alone is insufficient for full understanding of visual performance. Decrease in contrast sensitivity and color perception measure distinctly different properties of vision and combine with impairment of visual acuity to interfere with activities of daily living such as mobility at low levels of illumination, perception of stairs and curbs, driving, reading, using tools and sewing [17-19]. This multi-faceted impairment of vision is particularly significant in patients with CCM and brachytherapy in the better-seeing eye and in patients with subsequent loss of vision in the better-seeing fellow eye.
Of practical importance, change in visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision was statistically significantly correlated at 1 year, 2 years and 3 years after brachytherapy. Thus, visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision generally declined simultaneously in the period after brachytherapy.
Concerning prognosis, this study confirmed several risk factors for brachytherapy-related vision loss reported in other studies [5, 6, 20, 21]. For example, this study of 37 patients (37 eyes) with CCM treated with I-125 brachytherapy reported mean visual acuity at baseline, 1 year, 2 years, and 3 years after brachytherapy as 20/32, 20/50, 20/80 and 20/125 respectively (Table 1). The COMS report of 623 patients (623 eyes) with choroidal melanoma treated with I-125 brachytherapy described median visual acuity at baseline, 1 year, 2 years, and 3 years after brachytherapy as 20/32, 20/40, 20/50 and 20/125 respectively. In addition, this study and other reports identified greater risk of visual acuity loss associated with mid-choroid or macula tumor location, large tumor size, radiation maculopathy and radiation optic neuropathy (Table 2). These findings of visual acuity loss and relative risk for severe impairment of vision are useful in patient counseling and follow-up care. However, it should be noted that individual patients have a wide range of vision loss in response to brachytherapy and counseling should recognize individual variability.
Finally, comparison of the CCM eyes with fellow eyes in this study identified decrease in visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision in CCM eyes prior to brachytherapy. Thus, impairment of central vision in melanoma eyes after brachytherapy is the result of both melanoma-related and brachytherapy-related central vision loss. Retention of normal vision in the fellow eyes 3 years after brachytherapy generally mitigated the functional impact of vision loss in the melanoma eyes and emphasized the importance of ophthalmologic care for the fellow eyes.
Relative strengths for this study of central vision in CCM eyes treated with brachytherapy are prospective design, protocol refraction prior to each assessment of central vision; measurement of best-corrected visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision at baseline prior to, 1 year after, 2 years after, and 3 years after brachytherapy; correlation with melanoma size and location; and corresponding measurements of central vision in the fellow eyes. Relative weakness is the limited sample size of 37 patients.
In summary, this study of 37 patients (37 eyes) with choroidal and ciliary body melanoma treated with I-125 brachytherapy and followed for 3 years showed statistically significant and progressive mean decrease of best-corrected visual acuity, contrast sensitivity and color vision in the treated eyes. Greater decrease in visual acuity 3 years after brachytherapy was correlated with mid-choroidal and macula tumor location, baseline tumor height of ≥ 4.1 mm, radiation maculopathy and radiation optic neuropathy.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
The authors confirm that this article content has no conflict of interest.
Authors acknowledge support by Research to Prevent Blindness Unrestricted Grant and the George and Ruth E. Moss Trust.